Irish Genealogy Toolkit logo

Irish plum pudding and brandy butter recipe

Irish plum pudding

Irish plum pudding accompanied by brandy butter is part and parcel of a traditional Irish Christmas food feast although it is doubtful that the dessert we eat today would be immediately recognisable to our ancestors who lived through the 18th century. Their version was lighter – in both weight and colour.

Irish Plum pudding
Over the years, as more exotic ingredients have become available, the Irish plum pudding we know and love today has evolved.

The following recipes are guaranteed to finish off Christmas Dinner in fine form. It comes with three warnings, however:

Adding some small coins is fun but make sure your dinner guests know they might bite into something hard. No one wants an emergency dental bill added to the expense of Christmas.

You'll be tempted, but don't eat too large a portion of this rich pudding or you won't be able to move from your chair!

Under no circumstances eat Irish plum pudding before taking part in a Christmas Day swim. It might make you feel a bit warmed, but you will sink. Simple.

Ingredients for Irish plum pudding

Brandy butter

This is a very simple brandy butter recipe that can be made two or three weeks in advance of its arrival on the Christmas dinner table. Because you get to taste it as you go, you'll find it puts you rather nicely in the Christmas spirit! You can freeze it if you wish, but it keeps well enough in the fridge without being frozen.


  • 6 tablespoons brandy
  • 6oz/175g unsalted butter
  • 6oz/175g soft dark brown sugar.


    Using either a food processor or a hand whisk, blend the room temperature butter with the sugar until it is soft and creamy. Once it is smooth, add in a small quantity of brandy. Mix well. Repeat until all the brandy is used up. Taste, and add more brandy if you think it needs it.

    Put the mixture into a sealed container and wait for Christmas Day. Serve, as cold as possible, with plum pudding.

  •    3oz/90g/ white breadcrumbs
  •    1½oz/45g plain flour
  •    2 eggs
  •    4oz/115g demerara sugar
  •    4oz/115g prepared suet
  •    4oz/115g sultanas
  •    4oz/115g raisins
  •    4oz/115g currants
  •    2oz/55g sliced almonds
  •    1oz/30g chopped cherries
  •    2oz/55g peel
  •    ½ lemon, rind and juice
  •    ¼ tsp nutmeg
  •    ½ to 1 tsp mixed spice
  •    pinch of bicarbonate of soda
  •    salt


    Mix all the dry ingredients together in a bowl, then add lemon rind, juice and eggs. Mix really well. Place the mixture in a well-greased 1½ pint/850ml bowl and cover the bowl with two well-greased pieces of greaseproof paper. Steam the mixture for six hours and then remove the paper.

    Ignore any fat lying on the top of the pudding as it will be absorbed. Once the pudding is cold, recover it, still in its bowl, with fresh paper and store it for up to three months. You can douse it in rum or brandy occasionally if you like a pudding with a kick. On Christmas morning, steam it for three hours.

    A traditional Irish plum pudding is brought to the table aflame. Obviously you need to take extra care doing this. Before serving, pour brandy or any other alcohol over the pudding and set it alight.

    ←   top of page

    Choose from selection of Related Pages, or go to Irish Genealogy Toolkit Home
  • | Home Page | Disclaimer | Contact |Sitemap|Privacy Policy|

    By Claire Santry, Copyright© 2008-2018 Dedicated to helping YOU discover your Irish Heritage.
    Return to top